Batter Up!

Torie Wilson

New York Yankees third baseman Alex Rodriguez has been a media fixture in the past few years—and we're not just talking ESPN. He's been attached to some famous blond bombshells over the years, most recently to his current girlfriend, former WWE wrestler and model Torrie Wilson. Welcome to the gun show!

Cameron Diaz

Another fit blonde, Cameron Diaz, dated A-Rod for over a year. The dashing couple lived in the limelight but went their separate ways last September.

Kate Hudson

Kate Hudson famously rooted for then-boyfriend A-Rod when he was in the 2009 World Series. New Yorkers even held up signs thanking her at the victory parade, as Rodriguez had not performed so well in playoffs past.

Madonna

And before Kate, A-Rod very famously spent time with Madonna. (Are you sensing he's got a type?) The couple tried to keep a low profile, which is virtually impossible when you're one of these two people in Manhattan.

Jessica Biel

At the time in 2006, sporty and low-key Jessica Biel seemed like a perfect match for Yankees MVP Jeter.

On Wonderwall: See Jessica Biel's style over the years 

Adriana Lima

She may have ended up with an NBA star, but supermodel Adriana Lima once dated Jeter, too. We wish they'd had a child if only to see the gorgeous pair of eyes it surely would have had.

Vanessa Lachey

Before she married Nick Lachey, the former MTV VJ was spotted out and about in New York with the Yankees captain.

Jordana Brewster

Fast & Furious leading lady Jordana Brewster had a thing for the Yankees star back in 2002. They were first spotted together while celebrating Jeter's 28th birthday.

Mariah Carey

Jeter's first real foray into the gossip columns came via his relationship with pop diva Mariah Carey back in the late '90s. We never quite figured out how these two very different personalities came together.

Alyssa Milano

Jeter and Rodriguez haven't entirely cornered the market on celebrity girlfriends. Alyssa Milano is a huge fan of baseball... and its pitchers. She's dated Carl Pavano, Brad Penny and Barry Zito.

Hilary Duff

Another famous girlfriend of San Francisco Giants pitcher Barry Zito was pop starlet Hilary Duff. She promptly traded baseball for hockey when she met and married Mike Comrie, who just announced his retirement from NHL at age 31.

Eliza Dushku

Actress Eliza Dushku had quite a sporty summer in '07 while on the arm of then–Dodgers pitcher Brad Penny.

Mia Hamm

Nomar!!! Along with being the subject of one of our favorite old Jimmy Fallon/Rachel Dratch SNL sketches, Garciaparra is married to soccer star Mia Hamm. They've even got twin daughters, who we're guessing have some serious athletic chops.

Halle Berry

Halle Berry's first marriage—to then–Atlanta Brave David Justice—seemed at first like a fairy-tale pairing. Unfortunately, the ending wasn't so happy.

On Wonderwall: Find out what other surprising stars Halle Berry dated

Tawny Kitaen

Eighties heavy metal icon Tawny Kitaen married pitcher Chuck Finley back in 1997. It ended on a pretty sour note, but we like this image of the family at the ballpark during happier times.

Misty May-Treanor

Misty May is another Olympic star—in beach volleyball with partner Kerri Walsh—who turned into a baseball wife after marrying catcher Matt Treanor in 2004. They even have "M2" tattoos to symbolize their partnership.

Rihanna

One of the hotter new pairings in sports/entertainment was Rihanna and Los Angeles Dodger Matt Kemp. The couple split in December after nearly one year of canoodling.

Mamie Van Doren

On April Fools' Day 1963, movie star Mamie Van Doren became engaged to controversial baseball playboy Bo Belinsky. Their engagement ended before November of that year, but the two remained friends. The lefty pitcher referred to Mamie as his "physical therapist."

Ann-Margret

Four-time Golden Globe–winning Swiss actress Ann-Margret was briefly attached to the powerhouse Belinksy as well.